Select Page

How Google’s AI Overviews Are Changing SEO

 

Will AI replace SEO?

When Google rolls out a new feature, they usually nudge users to get on board by changing how things work—and AI Overviews are no exception. By now, most of us have seen them sitting high above the search results, even above the paid ads. And while Google has never been shy about overhauling its interface or shifting its algorithm to favor different types of content, this latest change feels different. Thanks to some eye-opening experiments by the team at HouseFresh, we’re starting to see just how off the rails things are getting. Instead of surfacing helpful, trustworthy content, Google’s AI is pulling from product listings, press releases, and sometimes even made-up info—pushing real creators and small businesses further down the page.

1. Google’s Becoming a Sales Funnel, Not a Search Engine

Search something simple—like “best air purifier”—and you’ll now see an AI-generated summary at the top, followed by ads, carousels, and a list of new things to click. All of it is pushing you deeper into a loop of sponsored content and paid placements.

Instead of helping people find the best, most helpful answers from independent sources, Google is becoming one big shopping guide.

2. The AI Is Repeating Marketing, Not Facts

This part is wild. HouseFresh actually created fake air purifiers and seeded them into press releases and product listings. Google’s AI Overviews picked them up and listed them like they were real.

Why? Because the AI is grabbing info from press releases, Amazon listings, and sponsored reviews. Ignoring the detailed, independent research that teams like HouseFresh do. Even when users specifically ask for cons or downsides, the AI either ignores the question or makes stuff up.

So if you’re writing thoughtful blog posts or honest product reviews? There’s a good chance the AI just skips over your work entirely.

3. Good Content Is Getting Sidelined

This is the real punch in the gut. For years, the deal was: you publish helpful, high-quality content, and Google would reward that with traffic. That traffic helps you grow your audience, get leads, build authority, etc.

Now? AI Overviews summarize your content, stick ads on top of it, and sometimes don’t even link back to the original source. So your helpful answers get repackaged into a blurb… with no traffic, no credit, and no value back to you.

And if you’re a small team or nonprofit relying on organic search to reach people—you can probably feel how big a deal this shift is.

4. So What Can You Do About It?

This isn’t all doom and gloom, but it is a wake-up call. The search landscape is changing, fast—and small orgs need to adjust. Here are a few things that can help:

  • Double down on original content: Personal stories, case studies, testimonials, and local context still matter—especially stuff that AI can’t fake or find in a press release.

  • Build your own audience: Email newsletters, referrals, and community-based marketing give you more control than hoping Google sends traffic your way.

  • Think beyond search: Focus on real people and real problems. Whether it’s through helpful guides, social content, or local SEO—just keep showing up where your audience actually is.

  • Don’t stop publishing: Yes, it’s frustrating. But good content still has long-term value—especially if Google does course-correct in the future (and there’s a growing push for them to do exactly that).

Final Thoughts

Google isn’t broken—it’s just shifting toward a business model that doesn’t always benefit small creators or honest businesses. AI Overviews might look helpful on the surface, but as HouseFresh’s research shows, they’re mostly repeating sales language and squeezing out independent voices.

If you’re creating honest, helpful content, keep going—but also start thinking more about how to own your audience outside of search.

Thanks again to HouseFresh for doing the heavy lifting with their research. Their experiments are great and absolutely worth a read.